About Us

About the Goodie Girls


The Goodie Girls are Jamie Pikulsky and Joyce Stewart. They met in 7th grade at Tri-Valley South Jr. High School now Albert Gallatin South Jr. High School and became friends then truly bonding in High School in the Art department run by their mentor, art teacher and writer, Madelyn Cindric. After 3 years of shenanigans in the art room and graduating, Joyce went to Pittsburgh Technical College and received a degree in Specialized Technology in Graphic Design and Advertising in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania and Jamie went on to Penn State University and received her degree in Integrative Arts and a Masters in Special Education from National University and is a Certified Reading Specialist.

One of Joyce's side gigs was working for bakeries in Pittsburgh where she developed her cake decorating obsession and shared her experience and knowledge with Jamie and Goodie Girl(z)s was born.

Joyce Toth-Stewart


Raised in Southwest Pennsylvania, Joyce was determined to be an artist from the age of 5 years old and spent her entire life studying and practicing many forms of art and design. While in high school, clay sculpting was a hobby and part time job to earn extra money but the skill was helpful when transitioning to sculpting fondant. After college she worked in various print shops and advertising agencies in Pittsburgh PA for 8 years and another 8 years in Tampa Florida. Joyce helped start an advertising agency with her friend and continues to freelance for Stratix Marketing based out of Tampa, Florida. She married her college roommate and friend, Jeremiah Stewart and has two children, William and Josephine. When she is not sculpting cakes and being a mother, she is a board member of the Fayette County Historical Society and in charge of scheduling the monthly society meeting presentations and their marketing guru to design print items for exhibits at their museum in the Abel Colley Tavern and the Searight's Tollhouse on the National Road. She enjoys dance and music (Heavy Metal and Bad 80's music mostly) & going to concerts with her husband and friends. Other hobbies include constant renovations to her home: painting, sanding and staining floors, and decorating for the holidays.

Jamie-Tait Pikulsky


Raised in Southwest Pennsylvania, Jamie excelled all through school growing up receiving many honors for her academic achievements. She spent her high school days in the art room with Joyce crafting and clay sculpting as well as raising money for the art club. She earned a Bachelor’s Degree from Penn State University in Integrative Arts. During college, she worked in screen print shops and interned at a jewelry studio in Santa Fe, New Mexico. After reaching her destination in Sacramento, California, she began her 18 year teaching career. Upon returning to Pennsylvania, Jamie began working for the IU teaching children with emotional and behavioral disorders and spent the last 2 years as a mail carrier for the Brownsville Post Office. She is married to her college best friend, Jeff Pikulsky and has two children, Leah and Elora. When she is not sculpting cakes and being a mother, she is raising money for the Leukemia and Lymphoma Society and the Mario Lemieux Foundation. For fun she also runs marathons (psycho) and enjoys CrossFit.

Menu / Price List

Above is a simplified menu of the items we offer. Orders for elaborate custom designed cakes must be placed with at least 2 weeks notice or be subject to a rush order fee. Sculpted 3D cake prices vary and depend on using additional fondant or modeling chocolate and intricate sculpted figures that requires many (wo)man hours of work or additional structural supports that need purchaced or created.

Contact Us

How Can We Help You?

Let's Create Some Magic!

To build a cake for your event we will need to know how many people you will need your cake to feed, the date of the event and details on design of what you are looking for in the email including flavor of cake; fillings desired special dietary concerns. Also if you need your cake delivered we will need the address to calculate the mileage cost for set up.

For other inquiries, questions, and general info, email and please allow 24-48 hours for a response.

Goodie Girls Cake Shoppe

90 West Main Street, Uniontown, PA 15401, US



Open today

10:00 am – 05:00 pm